Friday, April 28, 2023

Salt Lake City Cemetery (Part 2)


The Salt Lake City Cemetery is by far the most historic graveyard in Utah. Anyone familiar with the history of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints will recognize numerous Apostles, Prophets, and other prominent figures. Additionally, there are hundreds of lay pioneers buried alongside their ecclesiastical leaders. Catholics and Jews also have their own sections near the Mormons. 

The cemetery covers over 150 acres and has 9 ½ miles of roads. It is one of the largest city-operated cemeteries in the United States. It lies in the Avenues of Salt Lake City, up in the foothills. The first burial was of a child, Mary Wallace, in 1849. 

The last time I visited the Salt Lake City Cemetery was in search of my own ancestor, John Workman. As far as I knew, he was my only relative buried here. But once I got home, I quickly learned I was wrong—I had four more. Now it was my turn to find the graves of Samuel and Phoebe Merrill, and John and Mary Snider. 

And there was more to explore. Last time I had barely scratched the surface of what there was to see. Jenna and I set out in early November after a doctor's appointment at the Huntsman Cancer Center. As fate would have it, we were hit with an early winter snowstorm, covering headstones and fall leaves in a blanket of wet powder. 

Samuel and Phoebe Merrill.

Grave marker for the Merrill family.

It didn't take long to find the graves of my fifth-great-grandparents, Samuel and Phoebe Merrill. A large stone monument marks the plots of several family members. Phoebe died in 1862 and Samuel sixteen years later. A son-in-law, Thomas Williams, constructed the memorial. He included two of his own children that died in 1850 and 1853, as well as a brother. 

Samuel and Phoebe were of hardy pioneer stock, having joined the church in its infancy in 1838. They were baptized by another ancestor of mine, Joel Hills Johnson. They lived in Nauvoo, Illinois and were acquainted with the prophet, Joseph Smith, with whom Samuel traded horses. After the prophet's martyr, they migrated westward with the Saints, arriving in the Salt Lake Valley in 1847. Samuel was in his late sixties at the time. Of Phoebe it was said she “had a reputation for discovering sick or discouraged people and nursing them back to good health. Her talent made her a great asset to the Church in its early years." 

Salt Lake City Cemetery.

Gravestone of Temperance Bond Mack.

One of the many headstones that caught my attention was that of Temperance Mack Bond, who had died in 1850 at the age of 79. There was something that stood out to me, but I didn't know what it was. After returning home I did some research and leaned that she was the sister-in-law of Lucy Mack Smith, mother of the prophet, Joseph. 

As far as I can tell, Temperance was the only sibling in the Mack family to make the trip west with Brigham Young and the Saints. She didn't convert to the church until in her seventies. According to her own words: “I had full confidence in Lucy Mack Smith when she told me that her son had a vision and talked to God.” 

Temperance traveled to Utah with her daughter Almira and husband, Benjamin Covey. Temperance would pass away just two years after arriving in the Salt Lake Valley, never again seeing her other children. Through her daughter, Almira, there would be many faithful members of the church brought into this world. One of her direct descendants is Stephen Covey, a famous author, businessman and motivational speaker. 

Family plot for the Hunter family.

Further up on the slopes of the cemetery, I found another memorial that caught my attention. The name “Hunter” was etched along a vertical slab of stone and it sat inside of a family plot with other markers covered in snow. Hunter is a common name in Utah, and I wondered if by chance this man was the patriarch of them all. I stepped closer to the stone to catch the full name. It was Edward Hunter, who died in 1883. 

As with most buried in this cemetery, I knew this man had numerous untold stories and descendants as the sands of the sea. A succinct biography of Edward Hunter from the website, Find a Grave, reads: “Presiding Bishop of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints. Baptized by Orson Hyde, he sold all his land and possessions, moved to Nauvoo, and gave all to the Prophet Joseph. He also served for some time as one of Joseph's many bodyguards. At the time of the martyrdom of Joseph and Hyrum Smith, he helped hide the bodies for fear of desecration by enemies of the Church. At the death of his dear friend Bishop Newel K. Whitney, Bishop Hunter was ordained Presiding Bishop by President Brigham Young and Apostle Heber C. Kimball. He then selected these two men as his counselors in the Bishopric. He also helped lay the cornerstone of the Salt Lake Temple.” 

Headstone of Caleb Baldwin.

I had an experience several years ago with an older gentleman on my mail route. His name was Ben Baldwin and when I asked him about his roots, he began to speak fondly of his great-grandfather, Caleb Baldwin. As he spoke, a tear came to his eye. It wasn't a tear of sadness, but of love. He spoke of his great-grandfather being a valiant and faithful man. Then he added that Caleb spent four months in Liberty Jail with Joseph Smith in 1838. During that time Joseph used him as a scribe to pen several letters to the Saints. 

As I roamed the Salt Lake Cemetery that day, I came across Caleb Baldwin's grave. A smile came to my face and I thought of Ben and the admiration he had for his grandfather. 

I also recognized the name of Caleb Haight. He died in 1851, shortly after he arrived in the valley. He was the father of Hector Haight, one of the original settlers of Farmington, Utah, as well as Isaac Haight, one of the primary culprits in the Mountain Meadows Massacre.


Grave of Caleb Haight.

Reynolds Cahoon.

The name “Reynolds Cahoon” rang familiar to me, and I knew that I had read it in the Doctrine and Covenants, a sacred book of scripture for members of the Mormon faith. In D&C 61:35 it reads: “And let them journey together, or two by two, as seemeth them good, only let my servant Reynolds Cahoon, and my servant Samuel H. Smith, with whom I am well pleased, be not separated until they return to their homes, and this for a wise purpose.” 

There's another interesting story about Reynolds Cahoon. In 1834 while living in Kirtland, Ohio, Reynolds' wife bore him a son. One day, as Joseph Smith was passing by, Reynolds called him and asked if he would bless and name his baby. The Prophet then did so and gave the name “Mahonri Moriancumer” to the child. When the blessing was over, he turned to Reynolds and told him that the name he gave his son was that of the Brother of Jared. Up until this time, the name of the Brother of Jared had been revealed to no one in the church. 

James E. Talmage.

Headstone of Apostle James E. Talmage.

The snow began to drop at a faster pace and our shoes were now becoming saturated in cold wetness as we meandered through the memorials. There, in a large stone of marble, now becoming difficult to read because of large white flakes, sat the headstone for James E. Talmage. The inscription reads: “1862 – 1933; EDUCATOR, SCIENTIST, APOSTLE; 'Within the gospel of Jesus Christ there is room and place for every truth thus far learned by man, or yet to be made known.' - J.E.T.” 

In the church, Talmage is known for authoring the influential book, Jesus the Christ. During the year of 1914 he was given a room in the Salt Lake Temple where he studied and wrote the book. It took him seven months to complete the writing and he wrote it all in longhand, using a pencil. 

Archibald Gardner, patriarch of a large family.

The headstone of Archibald Gardner caught my attention. It is well known that in the early days of the LDS Church that some members practiced plural marriage. It wasn't uncommon for a man to have two or three wives. But Archibald Gardner, judging from his headstone, had eleven! Six are buried next to him in Salt Lake while the others are buried elsewhere. 

He was born in Scotland in 1814, and died in Salt Lake in 1902. The bottom of the marker quotes a portion of his Patriarchal Blessing: “A posterity shall keep thy name in remembrance forever.” 

View of Salt Lake City Cemetery, looking north.

Burial plot of Hosea Stout.

One common theme I saw as I roamed the lawns of the cemetery was the sheer amount of pioneers who were with the Saints in the early days of the church. Another such person was Hosea Stout. He is an important person in the history of the church because of his diligent effort in keeping a daily journal. He was an eyewitness to many early events. 

Having joined the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints just a few years after the publication of the Book of Mormon, Hosea Stout was a fiercely faithful member of the church. He had many personal assignments which gave him close contact with high-up leaders. He was one of many body guards to Joseph Smith. In 1851 he served a mission to Hong Kong, in which he dedicated the land of China to missionary work. 

Orrin Porter Rockwell.

Perhaps the most infamous burial in the cemetery is that of Orrin Porter Rockwell, also known as “The Destroying Angel.” Rockwell, who was also one of the earliest members of the church, never learned to read or write, yet he was one of the most loyal defenders of Joseph Smith. There are many stories and legends of him protecting the prophet from those who would do him harm.

He was large and powerful with long flowing hair. On Christmas of 1843, he was given a blessing by Joseph Smith that if he never cut his hair then “no bullet nor blade can harm thee.” This colorful figure in Mormon history has been the subject of numerous books and movies. It took us a while to find his grave, but it ended up being not too far from my grandparents, Samuel and Phoebe Merrill.

Porter Rockwell, one of the most notorious people buried in the cemetery.

Occasionally a headstone will literally tell a story. Such is the case of Joseph Standing, a missionary for the church who was murdered in 1879. A five-foot monument reads: “Martyred for the testimony of Jesus Christ, while with Elder Rudger Clawson, through whose heroism the body was afterward rescued, July 21st 1879, Varnell Station, Whitfield County, Georgia, by an armed mob of twelve men . . . His murderers were indicted and two of them tried, the first on a charge of murder and the other for riot. Through bigotry and prejudice, both were acquitted. Evidence of guilt was not lacking, but the assassins boasted, 'There is no law in Georgia for the Mormons.'” 


Telling headstone of Joseph Standing.

Further up on the hill, next to a narrow cemetery road, stands a very tall obelisk commemorating John Taylor and his family. He became the third President of the Church in 1880. 

A notable story of John Taylor came in 1844 at Carthage Jail. A mob of some 200 men with painted faces broke into the second floor of the jail where Joseph Smith, Hyrum Smith, Willard Richards and John Taylor were being held. Amidst a storm of gunfire, the Prophet and his brother were killed. Taylor received several bullets in his arms and legs, but there was one potentially fatal ball that struck and was stopped by the watch in his breast pocket. Although seriously wounded, John Taylor would live another forty three years to the old age of 78. 


Distant view of John Taylor's grave and family plot.


Close-up of John Taylor's headstone.

John Snider.

If you recall, I had one last grave I had to locate: that of my fifth-great-grandparents, John and Mary Snider. Being a flat stone and probably covered in snow, it was a little more difficult to find. We knew it was in section five. With a little perseverance, we finally stumbled across it. 

It is fascinating to learn how much the early pioneers were intertwined. As I studied the life of John and Mary Snider, I became aware that their entrance into the Mormon faith came alongside future prophet, John Taylor. 

In 1833, Taylor served as a Methodist minister in Toronto, Canada. He led a group called “Students of the Scriptures,” which sought an increased understanding of the truth. The Sniders were a part of this group. They were searching for a true church that had signs of the primitive church, namely prophets, apostles, evangelists and gifts of wisdom, faith, tongues, healings and other manifestations. 

About this time, Heber C. Kimball of the Quorum of the Twelve Apostles, delivered a prophecy to Parley P. Pratt that there were people in upper Canada who would receive the gospel and would be baptized. Many miracles occurred as he made his way to Toronto. Here he taught many people, including those in this small group. Eventually, John Taylor and the Sniders were baptized, which would change the course of their lives. 

Wet gravestone of John and Mary Snider.

Having now found the final resting place of John and Mary Snider, I was satisfied with our sojourn in the Salt Lake City Cemetery. Besides, our toes were becoming numb in the wet snow and we had a long drive home. 

It's always a humbling experience to walk among the graves of those who gave everything for a cause in which they strongly believed. Their lives were filled with acts of faith.  They were impoverished by worldly standards, but found deep joy in the gospel. This land I walked on was hallowed ground. ♠ 

 

Link: Salt Lake City Cemetery (Part 1)